The Outlaws Scarlett and Browne by Jonathan Stroud

What worked:

Scarlett and Albert Browne are a picture of contrasting personalities. Scarlett is an outlaw, and the book opens right after she’s killed four bandits. She’s used to living on her own in the wild and uses her wits and agility to avoid posses and danger. On the other hand, Albert is naïve about the world, since he doesn’t remember ever being outside the walls of Stonemoor, a prison/hospital. Surprisingly, he’s extremely optimistic and cheerful with his new experiences, which drives Scarlett crazy. Their opposing personalities make their interactions the highlight of the book.

Scarlett’s character is an enigma. Readers don’t know where she comes from or how she becomes an outlaw. Her reputation has spread across all the lands, although she’s known by different aliases in different towns. Where did she learn her legendary thieving skills? Scarlett can be rather ruthless, so what motivates her to help Albert? Scarlett’s abilities with weapons are unbelievable, and they get her out of many dangerous situations. Readers may be surprised by her intelligence, though. Scarlett can’t read minds, but she always seems to know what others will do and plans accordingly. How many times can she escape situations where she’s outnumbered and outgunned?

The future version of Earth reflects the effects of world devastation. Trucks are the only form of rapid transportation, and boats with small motors or oars navigate the waterways. The area where London is located now has small islands along the Thames. Albert hopes to live safely there, since rumors say the people there will accept anyone, even deviants like himself. Visitors can find the Great Ruins, but readers are left to wonder what they might be. The Faith Houses now rule most of the lands, and most oppressed citizens live in fear. The Faith Houses support the experiments being done in Stonemoor, and agents use force if anyone opposes them. Wild creatures roam the lands, with Taints being the most feared.

What didn’t work as well:

The mystery surrounding Scarlett is interesting, but readers might want to know more about her past.  Also, the book is probably most appropriate for mature middle-grade readers due to its violent nature. The book doesn’t have detailed descriptions, but violence feels like a part of life and is to be expected.

The final verdict:

Readers at the older end of middle grade will enjoy Scarlett and Albert with their sarcastic, playful bantering. I’ve already read the next two books in the series and can tell you they venture in a new direction that’s equally entertaining. I highly recommend you give it a shot.