Clarice Bean, Smile by Lauren Child

What worked:

Clarice is much like any average middle-grade student, and the story reflects events that are significant to her. She’s put off choosing a topic for a class project until the last minute and then worries that she might have made a mistake. Her best friend moved away to San Francisco in the previous book, and a new friend who replaced her is still in Europe. Clarice still has a loyal friend named Karl to support her, as he understands and accepts all of her quirks. Clarice’s parents are struggling with challenges in their jobs, but Clarice suspects there might be more going on with her dad. Her younger brother becomes terrified of centipedes, and her older sister is moody. And then there’s the annoying neighbor who overreacts when Clarice or her siblings stand on or lean against her stone wall.

Clarice is a devoted fan of everything Ruby Redfort. She tries to never miss a show, and she reads and rereads the series of magazines featuring Ruby Redfort. Clarice likes her neighbor, Nice Sandy, although she’s a big distraction when talking through the Ruby Redfort program. The magazines present many topics, but the story focuses on the meanings of different smiles. Clarice often interprets others’ smiles and tries manipulating her mouth to convey different nonverbal connotations. The author utilizes a different font type to make these references stand out, as well as relevant quotes from Ruby Redfort.

The myriad of minor happenings fill much of the plot, but there are a couple of long-term conflicts running throughout. The neighborhood sidewalks are being lifted by tree roots, causing them to become tripping hazards. Clarice’s grandfather already has trouble keeping his balance, so walking the dog, Cement, can be dangerous. Some people want the trees removed, but others enjoy their beauty and want them saved. Clarice has a creative idea for her project and works hard with her older brother’s help. However, an unexpected problem arises, causing her to become sad and want to give up. Finally, her parents' job issues only worsen, and something needs to be done. Clarice surprisingly comes to the rescue.

What didn’t work as well:

The description of Clarice’s thinking often jumps from topic to topic, much like young minds are prone to do. However, it can be harder to keep track of what’s actually happening when other thoughts pop into her head.

The final verdict:

Young readers can connect with Clarise’s character and enjoy all of the ups and downs. The author infuses valuable lessons for life, including the importance of maintaining balance in our lives and in nature. I recommend you give the book a shot.