What worked:
The Muslim faith is at the center of the conflict as Nayra
faces various issues. She is celebrating the Ramadan holiday which requires her
to fast during daylight hours. Consequently, she feels weak and has trouble
focusing in school. Gym class is especially a problem since she can’t perform
while the class plays volleyball. A classmate bullies Nayra and isn’t
understanding or tolerant of her faith. People can be really mean. Nayra’s
mother only tells her to be tougher so every day at school presents
overwhelming challenges while home life doesn’t provide an emotionally safe
haven.
A djinn named Marjan escapes problems in the djinn-world by
pleading for help and bonding with Nayra. Marjan and a djinn-friend made a pact
regarding a gem but Marjan breaks the promise and needs to flee. The majority
of magic in the book arises when Marjan shares visions of her past so the story
doesn’t get complicated by impossible events. The djinn offers advice as Nayra
struggles with the bully, her best friend Rami, and other social
interactions. However, Nayra doesn’t always listen to the djinn’s suggestions so
her friendship with Marjan faces challenges of its own.
Nayra’s problems begin to carry over into their relationship
with Rami. The pair have an isolated location where they feel safe and can
discuss religion and life at school. Rami always offers support but she feels
ignored at times when Nayra becomes self-absorbed in her problems. These
feelings make sense since Rami is unaware that Nayra has started confiding in her
djinn. Nayra doesn’t realize what’s happening so the unspoken conflict simmers
throughout the plot.
What didn’t work as well:
I’m not an art expert so my comments come from my role as a
reader. Some parts of the graphic novel cause me to pause with unclear scene
transitions, abstract drawings, and panels of text that don’t always add to the
story. The concepts in the narrative are still intriguing.
The Final Verdict:
The book highlights a young girl’s struggles to practice her
Muslim faith despite conflicts arising at school, at home, and with her friends.
The abundant colorful pictures with text help the narrative flow although it
feels like there needs to be more development. Give the book a shot!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments unrelated to the books being described will be removed.