What worked:
The synopsis effectively summarizes what’s going on as
Sylvie finds herself in a camp for monsters. All of the activities have monster
campers in mind that includes an important program every morning called HURT.
This acronym stands for Human Understanding and Resource Training and the daily
activities are intended to help monsters live safely among humans. Sylvie is
the odd camper out since she’s part of the human race that threatens the
monster population. However, Sylvie actually received an invitation to the camp,
and the director and his raven pay special attention to her so she, along with
readers, will wonder if they already know her secret. Why would she be invited
to a camp full of monsters that already don’t like humans?
Werewolves, ghosts, witches, a goblin, and other monsters
are among the participants so Sylvie’s disguise as a vampire fits right in.
However, there’s only one other vampire at the camp (although she’s half-human)
and they share the same cabin. How is Sylvie supposed to hide her humanness
when sharing the same space with Vera, an actual monster? How is Sylvie
supposed to hide the fact that she doesn’t drink blood for meals, sunshine
doesn’t bother her, and she can’t change into a bat? Readers will realize
Sylvie will eventually be discovered but they have no way of knowing when or
how this will happen. The anticipation creates tension and suspense since
Sylvie has no idea how the monsters will react when they discover a human is
living among them.
Vera is an intriguing character as she has her own internal
conflicts overwhelming her mind. Being half-human makes her stand out from the
other monsters and she’s constantly reminded of her differences. A werewolf
bully takes every opportunity to torment Vera and Sylvie often feels the need
to step in and defend her. Vera tends to clam up when she’s attacked and overcome
with anxiety so readers are left to wonder what’s going on in her mind. Most of
the story deals with prejudice and conflict between monsters and humans in general
but Vera’s troubles are more personal. Sylvie shares some of the same issues as
Vera so will Sylvie ever fully open up to her cabinmate?
What didn’t work as well:
There are sections of the story where the counselors explain
human/monster relationships that come across as classroom lessons. They may not
be as interesting as other parts although they serve a purpose. It’s an easier,
quicker way to communicate important ideas that might be applicable to the
monsters’ “real world” and to the lives of young readers.
The Final Verdict:
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments unrelated to the books being described will be removed.