Many Voices: Building Erie, the Canal that Changed America by Laurie Lawlor

What worked:

This is a comprehensive history of how the Erie Canal connects a quickly growing country. It takes many decades for actual construction to begin, and the book explores the many conflicts involved in the process. European countries fought over the lands, and indigenous people fought to preserve their homes and cultures. Funding the project and determining a route for the canal took years to complete. Qualified engineers can’t be found in America at this time in history, and finding the thousands of workers needed is an additional challenge, including young children. Once construction finally begins, the book delves into the technology and design of the canal and the dangers the workers face. Weather, insects, explosions, and drowning take the lives of thousands of workers. The book winds up by covering the years following the canal’s completion and sharing its status and conditions today.

The abundant facts and information are accompanied by numerous graphics and book sections. Actual drawings, maps, and a few photographs allow readers to see locations, people, working conditions, and canal designs. A bibliography and source notes share the author’s sources if readers want more information about different topics. A timeline gives readers a quick summary of key dates shared in the book. A couple of pages provide suggestions for people wanting to visit the area today. An index helps readers looking for pages about specific topics.

What didn’t work as well:

The vast amount of information may be a bit much for young readers. There are many names, dates, countries, cultural groups, and political figures involved in building the canal. The narrative may be challenging for middle-grade readers, as it’s not simplified for younger minds. It’s probably most appropriate for upper middle-graders or teens.

The final verdict:

This book will make a wonderful resource for the Erie Canal information, but it’s most appropriate for mature readers. It seems to encompass every topic related to its construction and is supported by relevant citations. Overall, I recommend this book for young readers doing research. It’s not light reading.