Dawn of the Dragons (New Dragon City) by Mari Mancusi

What worked:

Most books depict dragons as huge, fire-breathing monstrosities, but Cinder is a young toddler in this story. Readers follow her for half of the book while a young human named Lucas shares the other half. Lucas rescues Cinder after she’s injured by a bear, leading to their unusual friendship. Most humans don’t believe in dragons, and the dragons know little about humans. Cinder’s point of view shows the dragons’ uncertainty about forming a peaceful alliance with humans, and they’re confusion while trying to understand human behavior. Dragons are described as sentient, loving, and fearful rather than mindless creatures of destruction.

Readers will understand the humans’ attitudes when curious visitors flock to town in response to dragon sightings. It’s reminiscent of vague UFO reports and people obsessed with aliens. YouTube quickly communicates rumors, leading to the town being overrun with conspiracy fanatics. The situation is fertile for misunderstandings and creates a conflict that’s threatening to erupt. Both sides mean well, but a lack of understanding between them undermines their efforts. Fear and anger only complicate the situation. Readers may see humans as the more conniving of the two groups, but you’ll need to decide for yourself.

What didn’t work as well:

The description of time passing seems off at times. The text may say a day or two has passed, but readers are left to wonder what happened during that time. Nothing seems to have changed, so it’s unclear why the text says time has gone by. Also, there are many minor characters, but Lucas is often alone. A brother and sister help him when needed, but it feels like they should have larger roles.

The final verdict:

Featuring an immature dragon will appeal to many young readers. Lucas and Cinder have a simplified view of the world, but perhaps adults can learn something from them. I recommend you give the book a shot.