The Vanderhoff Heist (Mystery at the Biltmore 1) by Colleen Nelson

What worked:

Elodie’s parents are famous detectives who investigate art thefts around the world. They won’t let Elodie accompany them on their trips but she’s learned investigative skills from talking with them. She wonders if anyone will want a young girl to investigate their cases but she’s confident she can do the job. A valuable piece of inspiration comes from her housekeeper, Ms. Rosa, who said that just because there hasn’t been a detective her age, why can’t there be one now? Elodie keeps track of clues in her notebook as she explores the elements of all crimes: suspects, motives, and how they were done.

The Biltmore holds many unique personalities as Elodie investigates the theft of Mrs. Vanderhoff’s earrings. Elodie is joined by Oscar, a daredevil young boy who is angry about moving to the hotel. Other residents become suspects although Elodie thinks they’re all so nice that she can’t imagine them as thieves. Mrs. Vanderhoff has accused her housekeeper of the theft but Agnes is the one who contacts Elodie about the crime. Freddie is the friendly doorman who has keys to all of the apartments. An orchid enthusiast had a falling out with Mrs. Vanderhoff and the kids note raising flowers is an expensive hobby. One of the Flying Wallendas lives across the courtyard and could have entered the apartment without using the door. Another resident has transformed his place into a bird sanctuary and might need money to care for them. It’s Elodie’s task to deduce the identity of the real jewel thief.

What didn’t work as well:

The plot is simple without serious complications so more experienced readers may be disappointed. As soon as Elodie finds a suspect she thinks of a reason why it can’t be them. It feels like the last suspect she finds will be the guilty party.

The final verdict:

Elodie is a charming character and the story is perfect for emerging mystery lovers. Cute, color illustrations are included to help bring the characters to life. I recommend you give this book a shot.