A Recipe for Robbery (Mystery at the Biltmore 3) by Colleen Nelson

What worked:

This is the third book in the series, and it has the same format as the previous two books. Elodie is the main character, and she’s solved two other mysteries at the Biltmore Hotel. She has learned sleuthing skills from her parents, world-famous art detectives, and follows a logical process to solve crimes. She examines the five W’s: who, what, when, where, and why. She identifies suspects using her method and eliminates those who don’t fit the W’s. She tries her best not to make assumptions that might lead her in the wrong direction. She’s always accompanied by her cute little terrier, which will appeal to young readers.

Oscar also lives at the Biltmore, and he’s helped Elodie since the beginning. His dream is to become a Hollywood stuntman, and he constantly practices his skills during the investigation. His antics add levity to the story, but he’s helpful this time in solving the mystery. Even Elodie is surprised at some of his insights. Oscar is broadening his stuntman ability by wearing a disguise and using a foreign accent. This new talent comes in handy during the plot’s climax. His appearance is shown in colorful illustrations, and additional pictures help young readers visualize the characters.

What didn’t work as well:

While the story is fine for young readers, older middle-grade readers may find it too simple. It lacks tension, as the crime lacks danger or dramatic suspense. The solution makes sense, and astute readers can figure it out.

The final verdict:

This book is wonderful for emerging readers, especially those with an interest in solving mysteries. The plot isn’t overly complicated, and Elodie clearly explains her detecting methods. I highly recommend younger readers give this book a shot!