Island of Skulls (The School for Thieves Book 2) by Peter Burns

What worked:

For readers new to the series, the characters are either students or members of the Guild of Thieves. The students are learning to become thieves, forgers, assassins, and to perform other criminal activities. They’ll eventually become members of the guild. The Guild of Thieves’ purpose is to maintain balance between the three main world superpowers. The guild stops one faction from dominating the others. The main, underlying conflict deals with Chevaliers, a branch group of former Guild of Thieves members with a goal to rule the world, not maintain balance. 

Tom is the main character, and he’s the least experienced student. In the first book, he’s rescued from life on the streets to study at Bradbury, the School for Thieves. Another conflict pits Tom against another student named Cassidy. Cassidy has strong, negative feelings toward Tom, but he doesn’t know why. Their mutual dislike continues throughout the story. Tom’s survival instincts, manifested while homeless and avoiding the workhouse, have been invaluable, and the other students often look to him for ideas. His closest friend is Maxine, but he’s developed a crush on Connie, an older student.

Most of the book is set on the island where the characters initially think they’re being quarantined from a deadly disease at the school. They learn that they’re actually searching for treasure and a secret weapon, even though they don’t have specific details. The author increases the suspense when readers learn that teams of experienced agents have already searched the island, with many of them dying from hidden explosives. The students encounter numerous secret boobytraps, exploring the island without any guidance. Later in the plot, they face deadly, experienced agents, looking for the same treasures and a weapon that will change the world.

What didn’t work as well:

Some readers may have problems with future criminals being featured in a book, but the kids behave like young characters in other books about secret schools. Tom cares about others and has a strong sense of doing what’s right. His feud with Cassidy is tiring, even after he learns the cause. 

The final verdict:

I highly recommend you read this series starting with book one. It’s an exciting adventure, full of non-stop action, mystery, and surprises. 

The Key to Avalon (The Joseph Affenham series Book 1) by H J Bumbleton

What worked:

The book has an effective introductory hook when Joseph is thrust into the middle of “incompetence” at the zoo. He saves the day by capturing a huge King Cobra, even though the zookeepers take all of the credit. Readers learn that Joseph has unmatched talent and knowledge of animals, just like his missing and presumed dead father. His mother has been dead for several years, but he still remembers pieces of advice she gave him. The author uses italics to mark these memories, and Joseph uses them to navigate difficult situations.

The plot takes an amusing turn when a hobgoblin joins the cast. Hobgoblins are known for being tricky and mischievous, and they possess a small amount of magic. It won’t reveal its real name, so Joseph and Ricky call it Redsocks, for obvious reasons. Ricky and Redsocks clash immediately, so readers will enjoy their playful banter and challenges. Redsocks is easily offended, and characters will be targets for his embarrassing spells. Joseph and Ricky are surprisingly joined by a classmate named Daisy, and she comes with mixed contributions. She tends to overreact to situations and has a huge fear of most animals. On the other hand, her knowledge of mythical stories helps the group survive numerous dangers and terrifying beasts.

The antagonist is a hunter who captures and kills creatures for sport. Redsocks enters the story when Joseph and Ricky rescue him from the hunter’s cage. The boys foil the hunter several times, along with his gang of armed henchmen. However, the hunter is relentless, and he continuously reappears at critical moments. Readers will assume he wants to bag magical creatures, but he’s really searching for a magical artifact found in Avalon.

What didn’t work as well:

The dialogue can be challenging to understand. The exact meanings when Ricky and Redsocks speak are especially difficult, although readers should be able to capture the gist of their speech. Also, readers may wonder how Joseph and Ricky come upon a variety of mythical creatures without passing into a magical world. There haven’t been any news stories or rumors about them.

The final verdict:

The plot is an entertaining mixture of adventure, humor, and heart. Joseph discovers his destiny to follow in his father’s footsteps, and he’s surprised by secrets about his parents. I recommend you check out this book for yourself. 

Astra Fox and the Rise of the Wonderworkers by Isaac Fitzsimons

What worked:

Astra is a sympathetic character, as she’s treated poorly at the orphanage. She’s frequently and severely punished and is separated from other orphans. Her hope is that someone will claim her when they discover her wonderwork ability. Those who wield wonderwork are called gilders. Astra creates amazing illusions, but many people hate all wonderworks and think it shouldn’t exist. That means gilders like Astra shouldn’t exist. Another underlying problem is that Astra doesn’t know where her sister lives, but her ultimate hope is to be reunited. Some chapters begin with letters from her sister, always sounding hopeful that they’ll be together again. 

Astra is claimed by a wealthy benefactor, and she’s taken to Bellamore Hall in Empire City. There, she discovers two large problems. First, prejudice against gilders is ever-present, as evidenced when Astra isn’t allowed in a store without an escort. Secondly, she finds parts of the city without wonderworks, where dark, dirty buildings seem like they can fall at any moment. Astra realizes Bellamore Hall’s appearance is an illusion after she discovers a dark, moldy, crumbling room. She eventually ends up in the Bellamore Factory and is thrust into the middle of the wonderworks conflict. The working conditions are deplorable, and gilders are getting hurt or dying. Astra is torn between helping the other workers while avoiding the wrath of Mr. Bellamore. Non-gilders enjoy the fruits of wonderwork, but they don’t want gilders to have any rights. The situation is reminiscent of slavery.

The author creates vivid mental images with a masterful gift for words and language. Descriptions of wonderwork creations are colorful and eloquent, enabling readers to “see” the gorgeous scenes. “Sprawling ivy… leaves ablaze in hues of crimson, amber, and gold.” A “grand marble staircase” led to the manor’s front door, and “towering columns stretched skyward…they brushed the clouds.” Readers learn about Astra’s personality when the author says, “But Astra’s greatest talent was outrunning her better judgment.” 

What didn’t work as well:

Wonderworks create illusions, but they don’t change the essence of reality. Gilders can make food look and taste better, but it can’t make moldy food more nutritious or rickety buildings more stable. These inconsistencies may bother some readers, although the story eventually addresses them. 

The final verdict:

The story deals with civil rights for a discriminated group of gilders. Astra’s emotional rollercoaster will lead readers on a troubling adventure that pits the existence of wonderworks against the rich and powerful. I recommend you give this book a shot. 

Transylvania County by Jenny Howard

What worked:

Dig’s father hopes Dig’s behavior will improve after spending time with his cousin, Elliot. Elliot is a model student who follows all the rules, so his parents hope that he’ll be a better role model for Dig. However, Dig knows he doesn’t do bad things because of his friends; Dig is the bad influence on others. He is impulsive and rebellious, but he also cares about other people. He’s angry when his grandfather is the target of a prank and later loses his job for something he didn’t do. Dig is repulsed by the new P.E. teacher, Coach Renfield, who tries to get the students to stop caring about each other. Dig protects his cousin during dodgeball and is furious when Elliot is hit in the nose. Dig’s behavior can seem delinquent at times, but readers will begin to understand that he has good intentions. 

The story quickly confirms the scary rumors surrounding Transylvania County when Dig runs across an eight-foot, hairy Boojum with yellow eyes. The adults think he’s making up stories for attention. Dig can’t call the police, since his uncle, the county sheriff, is the first person to say he’s lying. Dig’s encounter with the Boojum adds credibility to tales of Dracula being entombed somewhere in the surrounding forest. This mystery becomes the plot’s focus when Dig and Elliot suspect someone of trying to locate Dracula. They’re convinced it has something to do with their grandfather, and their main suspect is Coach Renfield.

It looks like each book in the series will feature a different monster. Dracula and the Boojum are highlighted this time, while it appears werewolves will be the stars in the sequel. Elliot has ample general knowledge, but researching specific information is his superpower. He knows the local legends surrounding Dracula, has read Bram Stoker’s novel, and his knowledge of Latin comes in handy. The author adds to the mysterious ambiance through her descriptions of the setting. The town is located amid remote, forested terrain, and rainy skies and dark nights add to the gloom. Plenty of shadows can be found where surprises are hidden.

What didn’t work as well:

Readers will wonder about Dig’s mother, since she’s not in the story. Dig talks about what his parents will think or do, but his mother isn't present. Also, it takes a while for the promise of monsters to be fulfilled. Dracula's appearance is as expected, while the Boojum is a surprise.

The final verdict:

Dig is the highlight, as readers will be impressed by his daring (even though he has a crippling fear of bats) and willingness to help others in need. The climax will please monster lovers. I recommend you try this book for yourself.

Firebloom by Justin Davies

What worked:

Tally hopes to become a Sting Winkler like her grandfather, mother, and Smuck ancestors, but doesn’t know if it will happen. Sting Winklers normally show their abilities before the age of twelve, so she’s extra worried when she can’t communicate with the jellyfish when the Firebloom Festival starts. The townspeople expect her to become a Sting Winkler, and her grandfathers tell her that it will happen someday. Tally is not so sure. She feels more pressure this year after the jellyfish fail to shine their light, disappointing everyone, including visitors who support the local economy. Everyone seems to blame Tally, adding to her mounting stress.

The author shows the importance of jellyfish in the town by describing the many products made from jellyfish Sting, a substance harvested from jellyfish tentacles. For example, Tally’s best friend, Farran, relies on a Sting lotion to calm his frequent panic attacks. The lack of a jellyfish light show becomes a mystery that Tally must solve. Her grandfather is a Sting Winkler, but his ability to communicate with the jellyfish is fading away. Tally thinks something is scaring the jellyfish away from coming near the shore, and they’re behaving strangely. One jellyfish stung her on the leg, and that doesn’t happen to members of her family. The Vorpal twins do their best to annoy Tally, and their mother is threatening Tally and her grandfathers. Tally has a tiny ally named Albert, a highly intelligent cliff rat. Young readers will enjoy his invaluable assistance and his tendency to pop up when he’s most needed.

What didn’t work as well:

The plot has a slow, steady pace, but doesn’t pick up until the end of the festival draws near. Also, jellyfish aren’t the cuddliest creatures, so they may not interest young readers. However, there aren’t many books that feature jellyfish, so their novelty may be an attraction.

The final verdict:

Featuring jellyfish is unusual, but the mystery of the missing light show is engaging as it unfolds. Readers will enjoy Tally’s struggle to live up to the community’s expectations, and the author saves a couple of surprises for later in the story. I recommend you give this book a shot.

Our Children in the Shadows by J.T. Bird

What worked:

Haven’s character is the highlight of the book. She’s confident, curious, mischievous, and sarcastic, and she loves snooping. These qualities and her intelligence result in an invitation to join the Guild of Whispering Shadows, a secret government organization. Haven isn’t the guild’s purpose, so readers are left to wonder what kinds of missions are in her future. Initially, Edith, head of the guild, doesn’t expect much from Haven, a “scallywag”, since she’s not from a noble family. Haven doesn’t like uppity, rude people, and she’s not ashamed of her background.

However, Haven must pass a trial before becoming a member of the guild. The plot’s first half focuses on this test, as she teams up with Sunny, another recruit, to follow a man and stop a massive weapons deal. Much of the trial is pretend, since a real one would be too dangerous, but it still gives Haven and Sunny chances to prove themselves. A subplot waits in the background, as newspapers report that several people have been murdered. The victims are turned to stone, and this is the first hint that the story will take a drastic turn. At the book’s midpoint, Edith reveals the existence of fantasy creatures, including a talking horse named Dale.

Haven’s is given her first mission in the book’s second half. She doesn’t understand why she’s tasked with investigating the stone murders, since she hasn’t even gone through training. She’s partnered with Sunny again, but this mission could get them killed. The author saves a huge surprise for later in the story that shifts the book more into the speculative fiction category. It makes Haven wonder about her safety when working with the adult characters.

What didn’t work as well:

Haven’s Cockney accent makes her difficult to understand, and a couple of characters would agree. Also, Haven is sarcastic and confident in her snooping abilities, so it’s surprising when she becomes frightened or anxious. She’s hard to figure out. Finally, a minor thought: illustrations of characters are found at the end of chapters, but placing them at the beginning would allow readers to speculate and anticipate upcoming events. As it is, the pictures have little impact.

The final verdict:

This fun speculative fiction book wonderfully blends intrigue, curious characters, and adventure with a touch of humor tossed in. I recommend you give this book a shot!

A Kingdom of Shadows (Lightseekers Book 1) by Emily Bain Murphy

What worked:

The Great Betrayal causes the diminishing light, along with other negative consequences. Evil and danger lurk in the spreading shadows, as evidenced by shadow-infected fruits. The characters encounter the Domino, a mist in the forest that sucks happy memories from unwary travelers. Everyone once possessed a little magic, a gift, but the Great Betrayal took it away. The land is now dark and depressing, and many characters hope to take advantage of those less fortunate. This setting makes Ehrit’s dream of light and hope stand out in stark contrast. The author saves a surprise for near the end, flipping the story upside down.

Ehrit is the “mysterious stranger” leading the characters to the Lake of Light, but the quest creates unease between Finn and his best friend Adrion. The boys have lived a life of thieving to stay alive, but Ehrit seems to live a life of honesty and hope. Finn finds it difficult to believe anyone can be kind and generous without wanting something in return. Finn begins to believe in the possibilities Ehrit is preaching, but Adrion is ever the skeptic. Finn is torn between loyalty to his best friend and the trust he is forming with Ehrit. Lydia, Finn’s younger sister, symbolizes goodness, and the siblings hold out hope of finding a mother they hardly remember. They still recall a bedtime song that may be the key to discovering their family history and future, and surprisingly, Ehrit knows the song, too.

Other characters join the group along the way, adding various motivations and personalities. One of them steals key ingredients needed to reach the Lake of Light, and Finn is suspicious of everyone. His feelings are ironic, since he’s been a thief for most of his life. Another group member suffers from a curse that limits how many words he can speak each day. He often points to tattooed words on his arms to circumvent the curse. Another girl likes to “boop” the others with playful, affectionate punches, and she becomes buddies with Lydia. Finn wonders if Ehrit can see into the future, because he always seems to know what will happen. Readers may notice similarities between Finn and Ehrit and begin to wonder if it’s significant.

What didn’t work as well:

The concept of increasing darkness is abstract and sometimes hard to understand. It’s not a big factor for the characters’ progress until shadow creatures pop up along the way. These obstacles are creative and infuse suspense. Some readers may interpret religion in the story, but it’s more spiritual than worshipping a god. The suggested reading level is eight and older, but eight is too young.

The final verdict:

This book offers a classic good-versus-evil story, although readers can’t always tell one from the other. The characters and creative plot are the highlights. I recommend you give this book a shot!