I gave this book a rating of four out of five. It's obviously a spin-off from the fairy tale about Jack and the beanstalk. The grown up Jack gives three magical beans to a thief named Nick. Nick intends to climb the beanstalk and bring back treasures, just like Jack did fifty years earlier. However, Nick discovers some unexpected dangers and meets the giant's wife and sons. One son is very intelligent and creative, while the other son is strong but not very smart. Nick realizes that the two sons take after their evil father and not their kind mother. Nick must make a choice between stealing the treasure that he desperately wants and saving a special person, as well as the lives of the millions of people on Earth.
This book was more entertaining than I expected. It sat on my classroom bookshelf for a couple of years, and it always interested me. However, I always seemed to find something "better" to read. I was expecting a story much like the fairy tale, but I was surprised at the creativity of the plot. The introduction of the two evil sons was an unexpected surprise. The beanstalk itself becomes more than just a piece of the setting; it's very important to the conflict and the resolution. The characters surviving the conflict end up living happily ever after.
This blog began in 2009, and it's transformed through different styles over the years. I've become a reviewer for the Young Adult Books Central (YABC) and posts for those books have their own look. I've also been a judge for Cybils.com since 2010 to determine the best books of the year in the category of elementary/middle-grade speculative fiction. You'll see reviews for these top books in some of my January posts from the past.
Monday, September 27, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This was my 8 year olds favorite book. She seems to just love high action. We are glad we happened upon your website. It looks like there are a lot of books her she will like. We just read The boy at the end of the world which we found on this site. She loved it. Thanks, Kris
ReplyDeleteI'm very happy you found a book your daughter enjoyed. That's why I created this blog! Hopefully, she'll enjoy other books I've read.
ReplyDelete