What worked:
Vin doesn’t want to cause trouble but her emotions build up
until she loses control of her magic. The rules at Last Hope School are very
different from what she’s used to as Vin’s first observations find students
wielding their magic in mischievous ways. The headmistress isn’t terribly upset
by the behavior so Vin doesn’t know how she’ll ever learn to control her magic
in this environment. Vin holds back when practicing her magic because she
always fears it will explode and destroy everything or hurt someone. And then
expelled. As with many middle-grade novels, Vin possesses a rare form of magic that
can make her a formidable sorcerer.
Three other students immediately become Vin’s friends
although she’s never had close relationships before. Even her parents have no
interest in her. The students are very patient and understanding as Vin
struggles to adapt to the new school. They all appreciate that there’s
something unusual about Vin’s powers and there’s no explanation as to how she has
a fire sprite hidden in her closet. Readers will wonder if the sprite will have
a bigger role in the story besides grumbling and becoming more agitated about
its captivity. The school has a self-centered bully (his power is based on
charisma) who has targeted Vin for teasing. It’s amusing to read about Vin
finally getting even with him and possibly giving him an attitude adjustment.
The narrative presents different aptitudes and attitudes toward
magic and these different sides create an underlying conflict. The biggest disparity
is between magic and non-magic folks but their differences are mostly addressed
by a treaty. The magical school board supports strong rules and guidelines for
sorcerers with uncontrollable students kicked out and discarded. The headmistress
at Last Hope won’t give up on any child which is why she’s reluctant to allow any
school board members inside the school’s walls. The Free Mages are made up of
rogue sorcerers who don’t want any restraints or limitations on their magic. Many
of them are angry outcasts and one of them is a former student at Last Hope
with a grudge to settle.
What didn’t work as well:
The plot follows Vin’s struggles to discover her abilities and to feel
accepted but it takes over half the book for the larger conflict to come to the
forefront. Also, the mysterious former student is easily identified even though
Vin has no suspicions until the plot nears its climax. However, the author
saves room for a few surprises including one that will affect the book’s
sequel.
The final verdict:
While the school seems similar to other middle-grade books, Last Hope
has a very different feel to it. Every student is unique and school activities
are unpredictable due to their unpredictable abilities. Vin’s pursuit to master
her magic leads to an exciting adventure within the school. Overall, I highly
recommend you give this book a shot!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments unrelated to the books being described will be removed.