What worked:
Many young readers love horses, and unicorns are even
better! The spelling in the book’s title refers to unicorns that have lost
their horns, and that creates the backdrop of the story. Mae’s mom had a
veterinary practice on an old farm, and Mae now helps tend the animals for the
farm owner. The animals have quirks, Percy the horse only eats goat food, so
readers know there’s something unusual about this place. The stump on Percy’s
forehead foreshadows his true identity.
The story deals with grieving and friendship. Mae’s father
is having a very hard time mourning his wife’s death, and he displays a wide
range of emotions common to the grieving process. There’s even a scene where
the book labels the various feelings he’s experiencing. With her father not always
thinking clearly, Mae relies on her friends and solicits help from two other
classmates. The friends are skeptical when Mae shares what’s going on, but they
stick by her and provide support.
This graphic novel is full of colorful, informative illustrations.
The pictures show the facial expressions of Mae and her father as they battle
emotions for the dead mother, and they help readers visualize the physical
transformations of a couple of characters. The visuals replace words during the
chase scenes, and they’re very effective through the fast-paced action. The
illustrations provide detail to the setting without using words that might slow
down the plot.
What didn’t work as well:
The graphic novel doesn’t fully develop characters, since
the artwork replaces descriptive words that might have been used. Readers can’t
thoroughly interpret underlying details by interpreting pictures. However, the
author is able to communicate a great deal about Mae, the main character, since
the plot is told from her point of view. The description of Mae and her
feelings is enough to carry the story.
The Final Verdict:
The innocent must be protected from evil. The authors deftly blend words and
illustrations to share this emotional story of loss and discovery. The colorful
pictures and exciting story will appeal to young readers, and I highly
recommend you give it a shot.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments unrelated to the books being described will be removed.